Bond Outlook
[by bridport & cie, January 23th 2002]
The Enron saga is about far more than the misdoings of one company
and its auditor. It is about faith in the American system of providing
reliable and truthful data to investors. All the bedrocks of
incorruptibility --auditors, investment banks, advisers on fiscal law
--look a lot less reliable. Adam Smith's historic view about the
temptation to collude, to which the business community is continually
prone, has returned two and quarter centuries after he wrote it (1776).
Faith that the free-market economy is self-correcting (because every one
wants every one else to be honest, and transparency of data ensure
visibility) was all the rage in books on business ethics written in the
early 1990s. That faith is seriously wavering and under threat because
transparency has given way to opacity, applying the spirit of the law to
fulfilling its letter, e.g. "off balance sheet is out of mind and out of
sight". The events in the USA will give a great boost to IAS
(International Accounting Standards) over GAAP (Generally Accepted
Accounting Principles). IAS will become obligatory in the EU in 2005 and
is being adopted by many other countries. Just possibly GAAP could also
accept the principle of auditors "following up" on all matters of
relevance, but the US audit profession has proven very resistant to such a
change, time and time again, which is partly why the founders of IAS have
moved ahead without the USA. |
|
The undeniable economic success of the USA has led to blindness to
any weakness in the system. The pro-business government stance, freedom of
commerce, lightness of labour laws, moderation in social charges, the
positive attitude to wealth creation - they are all wonderful features of
the USA. However, when the custodians of transparency deceive and deny
that they are deceiving, then it is legitimate to demand changes.
Fortunately, the US people and press will act where politicians have
totally failed. |
|
Many other denials are to be found over the USA. In earlier
weeklies we have called them the "need for rebalancing". They include
consumers spending beyond their means, share valuations based on future
profit growth levels never yet seen in history, and a dollar too strong to
reduce an external current account deficit of 6.2% of the
GDP. |
|
Part of the strength of the dollar is the lack of a viable
alternative. A feeble yen is "accepted" policy in the USA and Japan,
despite Chinese protests, and likely competitive devaluations throughout
Asia later this year. We have always believed a weaker yen will help bring
inflation, a much needed "evil" to encourage Japanese consumer spending.
Yet, alone, inflation cannot solve the problem, and even brings new
dangers with it. The greatest of these is that Japanese investors will see
135 yen to the dollar as a guaranteed dollar floor, so they will have
every interest in seeking better returns on non-Japanese bonds. The credit
risk on JGBs is increasing anyway, thus there is every chance that yields
will rise, and the fall in the yen continue. All to the good if money in
Japan finally achieves a positive time value, but, for the banks, very
costly. Not for nothing have their ratings been watch-listed negative yet
again this week. |
|
The euro should, of course, be a valid alternative to the dollar.
The strengthening we expected to see in 2002 has still not begun and may
have been an illusion. Our confidence that black marketeers and third
country reserve banks would buy euros and push up the value is being
seriously undermined by the likely joining of weaker economies in the East
and South. Moreover, it is really hard to associate a strong currency with
government policy, led by the French, to legislate against work.
Forthcoming elections in France and Germany could reverse the trend to
non-competitiveness, but we would not hold our breath! |
|
Opacity of accounting is not a purely US phenomenon. Look at German
banks, in particular, DePfa, the public sector and property bank, which is
now separating the operations and names of its two main activities. Will
Aareal Bank AG, the new name for the property bank, be more forthright on
the quality of the 2/3rds of its loan portfolio devoted to commercial
properties and much more vulnerable than retail mortgages? If you are
suspicious by nature, you would note that the DePfa Group reports
according to GAAP, not IAS, while the sister (public financing bank) has
been established in the tax/haven of Dublin. |
|
On the emerging market front, the spread movements cannot yet be
interpreted as a particular trend. For the strong-hearted, there could be
interest in Argentinean Brady "Pars" which offer significantly greater
value than the Eurobonds. Feel free to call us to run through the
arithmetic. |
|
Kmart has gone into
Chapter 11, and it will be hard to imagine a turnaround when suppliers
have pulled the plug. At the other end of the retail spectrum, Saks is not
at all happy about its downgrading. US consumers are still spending, but
they seem reluctant to grant the retailers much profit! |
|
Recommended average maturity for bonds in each
currency While we are not changing our average maturities, the bias
is towards further shortening. |
Currency: |
USD |
GBP |
EUR |
CHF |
Over the period
15.08.01 to 21.11.01 |
2008 |
2006 |
2011 |
2011 |
As of
05.12.01 |
2006 |
2006 |
2006 |
2006 |
|
|
The JPY continues to be in the spotlight of the foreign exchange
markets with the visit of US monetary officials meeting their counterparts
in Tokyo. They are discussing monetary policy, the weak economic
environment and the weakening yen. After meeting US manufactures the week
before, Mr O'Neill, US Treasury Secretary, commented only that it was up
the market to decide the appropriate level of the yen, and that the USA
was still interested in a strong dollar. The overall trend for the year
will be substantial yen weakness. The clean-up process inside Japanese
banks is still underway, but contains the potential for many on w nasty
surprises. A loss of confidence in the JGB market would be catastrophic,
not only for Japan but also for the international financial
system. |
|
EUR/USD: A quick test below 0.8800 was
short lived. Support comes in at 0.8750 and breakout level on the topside
is at 0.9010. Short term, we see some consolidation in this trading
range. |
|
USD/CHF: Again the US unit tested
a high of 1.6730, with the big breakout level on a weekly basis at 1.6780,
followed by 1.6900. Support comes in at 1.6500, followed by
1.6380. |
|
USD/JPY: The corrective move on the
downside has been short and quick. 133.00 was successfully broken on the
way to our first price objective at 136.90. Support is 131.80and 130.50
and resistance at 135.50,136.90 followed by 140.00 |
|
EUR/JPY: Consolidation in a 115.50 to
119.50 range. Medium term, we are looking for higher levels in the
direction of 125.- |
|
USD/CAD: We keep our short position
USD/CAD at 1.5955 with a S/L at 1.6300. Price objective is around
1.5650. |
|
AUD/USD: The Aussie has created a solid
base above 0.5000 but needs to break 0.5280 on a weekly basis to make
further progress, direction 0.5400. |
|
GBP/CHF: Extreme volatility will remain
in this cross. 2.3850 is acting as a pivot point, with a weekly close
above looking for 2.4100 or below for 2.3550. |
|
|
USD/CHF |
EUR/USD |
EUR/CHF |
USD/JPY |
EUR/JPY |
Resistance/Breakout |
1.6780 |
0.9030 |
1.4880 |
135.10 |
119.50 |
Current spot
level |
1.6635 |
0.8860 |
1.4730 |
134.10 |
118.80 |
Support/Breakout |
1.6380 |
0.8770 |
1.4650 |
132.80 |
116.80 |
|
AUD/USD |
NZD/USD |
USD/CAD |
GBP/USD |
XAU/USD |
Resistance/Breakout |
0.5310 |
0.4350 |
1.6210 |
1.4430 |
288.50 |
Current spot
level |
0.5195 |
0.4290 |
1.6080 |
1.4275 |
281.75 |
Support/Breakout |
0.5050 |
0.4180 |
1.5980 |
1.4250 |
278.50 |
|
|