Bond Outlook
[by bridport & cie, November 6th 2002]
Go with the crowd, or fight it? We have tried recently to go
against the crowd and have been proven wrong. A fortnight ago we said we
were considering shortening recommended average maturities, then last week
we proudly announced we were glad we had not. This week we must admit it
would have been better to have followed our first instinct. The stock
market rally has been massive over the last month, although not enough for
the Dow and S&P500 to reach the previous peak of mid-August (the
Nasdaq has). The success of the Republicans in controlling both Houses of
Congress, combined with the probable latest Fed cut this evening, are very
likely to reinforce the bullish tendency. There is therefore a continued
trading opportunity in stocks over bonds, and shortening, better late than
never, seems the best move as of today. |
|
We expect the BoE and ECB to follow the Fed's lead, not least
because a weak dollar is not what Europe really wants. The relative, but
not extreme, weakness of the dollar, combined with rate cuts and a
likelihood of more tax cuts, will help the stock markets, but not the
economy, although that seems not to matter to the US
Administration. |
|
Allow us to stress the trading nature of our recommendation today
to take profits on bonds. We can claim, by the way, that over the cycle of
our recommendation to lengthen and today's recommendation to shorten,
there are indeed good profits to take. We are not sure whether this stance
is the start of a long-term trend. The rate cut cannot in itself revive
industrial investment. Corporations do not decide to make an investment
because of a modest cut in financing costs; they decide as a function of
demand vs. capacity. Demand is not growing, and of capacity there is
plenty. Marginal profit improvement is being achieved through cost
cutting, not from revenue growth. Whether the cut will restore consumer
confidence and spending remains to be seen. That is what the
Administration wants, and damn the increased internal and external
deficits and their long-term effects. |
|
Just how long this trading opportunity will last is anybody's
guess. We are confident that the economy has to worsen before improving,
and that the latest developments can do nothing to obviate the long-term
need for the US economy to find internal and external balance. May we
again point out that, with PEs on the S&P500 at 33, the ratio of
possible upside gain to downside risk looks distinctively unattractive.
The change in sentiment back to bearishness could come at any time and
very quickly. |
|
Index-linked US $ bonds (TIPS) are gaining in value as yields move
up on Governments. To that extent, and despite our scepticism below about
what professional investors really believe, there is some consistency in
US market behaviour: a recovery would imply more inflation in due course.
In Europe, however, index-linked bonds are still deteriorating in price.
Readers must decide whether this implies a worse economic outlook for
Europe, or whether it just means that European investors are less inclined
to ignore fundamentals than American ones. |
|
To spot the return to renewed bubble unwinding, we expect a good
indicator to be corporate debt. The pressure on corporate bonds has eased
now. When it returns we shall see the spreads again move out. The spreads
on emerging markets have also come in. It really is as if the world were
coming nicely out of its turndown and the financial markets are reflecting
this. The only trouble is that there is no recovery, and the economies
have not shown their worst. All the data this week, on both sides of the
Atlantic, show increasing unemployment, decreasing industrial orders and
production, and declining retail sales. Only the service industries are
not in decline, but their growth is miniscule. Are financial markets
anticipating a recovery in six months? Maybe, but that argument has been
trotted out at every rally since early 2000! |
|
Comparisons with 1999 and the end of the hi-tech bubble come to
mind. However, there is a major difference. Then, "everyone" believed the
nonsense about a new economy. The sceptics, like ourselves, were just
occasional voices crying in the wilderness. This time round, there are so
many data and so many commentators pointing out the awful fundamentals,
that no investor has the excuse of not knowing about them. That points to
a cynical and self-fulfilling prophecy: the crowd wants the markets to go
up, so the professionals, even ourselves in our own limited way, are
running with them. Yet every professional must be ready at any moment to
turn and run back again to the safe haven of bonds. |
|
This is a traders' market, and the fundamentalists will have to lie
low till their day returns. |
|
|
Recommended average maturity for bonds in each
currency. Shorten as a trading
opportunity. |
Currency: |
USD |
GBP |
EUR |
CHF |
As of
10.07.02 |
2012
|
2007 |
2012 |
2012 |
As of
06.11.02 |
2007
|
2007 |
2007 |
2007 |
|
|
The Republican victory in the US midterm election will most
probably pave the way for additional tax cuts and soaring deficits over
time. Short term, however, this event is logically interpreted as positive
and pro business, which should help at least the equity
markets. |
|
For today, all eyes are on the FED. A cut of at least 0.25% rate
cut is already priced in. Much more important will be the message given to
market by the FED officials to see of how they judge the current state of
the economy. |
|
The question remains open as to whether the ECB and the BoE will
follow suit tomorrow. The weekly close on all currencies is going to be
decisive in seeing whether the recent weakening of the US unit is going to
be confirmed, or whether it is once again only a false breakout with
regard to the hopes of seeing the euro establishing itself above parity
|
|
EUR/USD: The topside at 0.9950 was
finally broken and a high so far of 1.0030 was reached. Only a weekly
close above parity would favour further euro gains. The next resistance is
1.0080, then 1.0150, followed by 1.0230. Support is coming in at 0.9930
and 0.9880. |
|
USD/CHF: Here as well, short-term
speculation has pushed the US unit through support at 1.4750 and managed
to trigger further stops to reach a low around 1.4535. The next big
supports are coming in at 1.4480, 1.4430 and 1.4350. A close above 1.4800
would abort any further attempts at the downside. |
|
USD/JPY: All our objectives on the
downside have been met with the subsequent breaks of 123.80, 123.30 122.50
to reach a low of around 121.30. A close above 123.00 is needed to abort
any further downside attempts. A broad trading band of 120.50 to 125.50 is
the most likely outcome over the next couple of weeks. |
|
EUR/JPY: Same comment: a 120.50 to
122.50 range is in place. Major support is at 119.50. The trend remains
towards the upper side. |
|
USD/CAD: 1.5650 looks to cap any attempts to
the upside for the time being. A loss of major support at 1.5480 would
again speak for a substantial appreciation of the
CAD. |
|
AUD/USD: It looks like a solid support
zone is starting to be built around 0.5480/0.5530. As long as the exchange
rate stays above this level, further gains might be possible, with
resistance at 0.5630, 0.5680 and finally 0.5750 |
|
|
USD/CHF |
EUR/USD |
EUR/CHF |
USD/JPY |
EUR/JPY |
Resistance/Breakout |
1.4780 |
1.0050 |
1.4730 |
123.10 |
122.30 |
Current spot
level |
1.4690 |
0.9955 |
1.4620 |
122.30 |
121.80 |
Support/Breakout |
1.4610 |
0.9930 |
1.4580 |
121.80 |
121.30 |
|
AUD/USD |
NZD/USD |
USD/CAD |
GBP/USD |
XAU/USD |
Resistance/Breakout |
0.5630 |
0.4980 |
1.5630 |
1.5650 |
313.00 |
Current spot
level |
0.5610 |
0.4955 |
1.5575 |
1.5580 |
308.50 |
Support/Breakout |
0.5550 |
0.4880 |
1.5510 |
1.5520 |
303.00 |
|
|