Bond
Outlook [by bridport
& cie, August 6th 2003]
Remember the three possibilities: stagflation, recovery with
inflation, deflation. For the USA, the view we have taken since the Fed
pulled its greenscam on investors (by first implying and then denying it
would buy long-dated T-bonds) is that stagflation is the most likely.
Recovery is unrealistic in an economy over-indebted in every way possible,
dependent on cheap money for its remaining strength, and with surplus
production capacity. Deflation, on the other hand, looks unlikely when
everything is in place for continued weakening of the dollar, which would
seem incompatible with deflation, since it pushes costs and prices up.
Higher input costs are now combining with more expensive money as the US
Federal Government borrows massively, and with households losing the
option of refinancing their mortgages to maintain their spending. That
means slow expansion of the economy at best, combined with rising prices,
i.e. stagflation. |
|
This conclusion, to us inescapable for the USA, should not be
assumed to be universal. In major economies with smaller indebtedness and
less spare production capacity, the case for stagflation is weaker, and
that for deflation stronger. A weaker dollar does not remove deflation for
the world stage, but shifts it from the USA to countries with appreciating
currencies. Chief among these is the euro, not least because Asian
currencies are stubbornly held down with the dollar. It is commonly
assumed that, whatever the USA, does, the rest of the world will follow.
It may now be possible that a dichotomy sets in, at least between the
European and US economies, as they follow paths of deflation and
stagflation respectively. |
|
Some major bridport clients appear to accept this dichotomy, as
they have massively lengthened their bond holdings in European currencies.
In addition, a comparison of European and US yields suggests less upward
pressure in Europe (66 bps yield increase in Bunds and 55 bps in Gilts,
vs. 120 bps for Treasuries from mid-June to end-July). Our own view is
that it is too early for lengthening in Europe. Two reasons make us think
that yields will rise further: increased government borrowing and improved
household spending as reforms take hold in Germany. The very idea that
Germany could be the engine of growth in Europe seemed ridiculous a few
months back, but today it seems at least possible. All in all, Europe has
a better chance of avoiding deflation than the USA has of avoiding
stagflation. |
|
There are still a couple of unresolved issues about US economic
policy. One is whether the Fed will, despite its past "on again/off again"
policy, intervene to buy T-bonds at mortgage-sensitive maturities of 5-10
years. It must be tempting for the Fed, as lower mortgage costs would
return the consumer prop that has just been knocked away. However, such a
move could only have temporary impact and would so smell of desperation
that we doubt that even Alan Greenspan would try it. The other issue is
the 30-year T-bond. The Treasury denies it will come back. However, if the
Administration wants to borrow without competing directly with the private
sector, the only option is to move to very long maturities. Watch out for
a gradual re-adjustment of public statements to prepare for this
possibility. |
|
The recent events of USD ten-year T-bond yields moving higher than
Bunds and Gilts, and the abrupt breaking off of US re-mortgaging
opportunities mean a period of financial turbulence has begun. Just about
every possible view may be found among commentators at present, ranging
from Snow's propaganda about the US economy being like a coiled spring
ready to expand, to an anonymous writer who sees gold at USD 3,500 per
ounce and massive collapse of the dollar and of the US economy. Our own
reflection leads us more moderately to stagflation in the US, to
hesitation between deflation and modest recovery in Europe and to hope for
economic leadership from Asia. Emerging markets are rather out of the
limelight. We nevertheless re-affirm our long-term faith in Russia, and
note that Lula has converted totally from revolutionary to reformer. The
market is having doubts about him, not so much over intention as over the
time it is taking. |
|
In the meantime, in Europe, countries with much lower labour costs
will soon be members of the EU. In which direction will they push Europe
as a whole? To deflation or recovery? A likely subject for us to consider
in a week or two. |
|
Recommended average maturity for bonds in each currency
|
|
Stay short until the current turbulence passes.
|
Currency: |
USD
|
GBP
|
EUR
|
CHF
|
As of
30.07.03 |
2006
|
2006
|
2006
|
2006
|
|
|